Monday, 30 May 2011

FOI Internal Review Request to Thames Valley Police re communication of fingerprint evidence to the Hutton Inquiry

This post consists primarily of the text of a Freedom of Information Internal Review Request sent earlier today to Thames Valley Police regarding the communication of (or failure to communicate) fingerprint evidence to the Hutton Inquiry.

Thames Valley Police Reference No: RFI2011000175

The issue is important since it helps to clarify where the "concealment of evidence" in relation to fingerprint evidence arises.

If Thames Valley Police communicated the fingerprint evidence to the Hutton Inquiry then the ultimate responsibility for the concealment of that evidence lies with Lord Hutton and counsel to the Inquiry.

If Thames Valley Police withheld the fingerprint evidence then that organisation's culpability regarding "concealment of evidence" is evident.

The text of the Internal Review Request is here:


Mr. Hopgood,

I write to request an internal review of your initial decision.

I do not accept that my request was "vexatious".

My request asks for information that, so far as I'm aware, neither myself nor anybody else has previously requested.

Additionally, you seem to have failed appropriately to have taken into account the time span since any previous FOI requests by myself which have been answered. In doing that it appears to me that your decision is wrong in terms of the Act.

Further, the seeming declaration in the email of 1st April 2011 and previous correspondence that any question from me about the "subject" of Dr. David Kelly's death is "vexatious" seems to me to be a transparent attempt at obstructing the purpose of the Freedom of Information Act by yourself and Thames Valley Police.

To the best of my understanding there is no power given in the Act to declare a "subject" off limits. It seems to me that this is what you are seeking to do.

Additionally, as I have expressed in previous correspondence, I consider that some members of staff in Thames Valley Police in 2003 and in 2010-11 may have "perverted the course of justice" with respect to the concealment of what I believe to be the murder of Dr. David Kelly. I view your obstructiveness with respect to Freedom of Information requests in that context.

You are, I believe, aware that I have formally written to the Chief Officers of Thames Valley Police regarding the matter of the perceived perverting the course of justice both in 2003 and 2010-11.

In that context I believe that I have a "proper or justified cause" as expressed on page 2 of the ICO guidance to which you refer. ( http://www.ico.gov.uk/upload/documents/library/freedom_of_information/detailed_specialist_guides/awareness_guidance_22_vexatious_and_repeated_requests_final.pdf )

Since, in my opinion, the evidence indicates that Thames Valley Police is engaging in the process of perverting the course of justice in relation to a murder, it seems to me that a powerful case can be made on appeal to the Information Commissioner that I have a "proper or justified cause".

In the interests of transparency and public accountability, I anticipate that the text of this email will be posted on my "Chilcot's Cheating Us" blog: http://chilcotscheatingus.blogspot.com/ or my "Come Clean on Kelly" blog, http://comecleanonkelly.blogspot.com/ .

I look forward to your reply.

Thank you

(Dr) Andrew Watt

FOI Refusal by Thames Valley Police re communication of fingerprint evidence to the Hutton Inquiry

This post consists largely of a Freedom of Information Refusal by Thames Valley Police dated 1st April 2011 in relation to a request relating to whether or not Thames Valley Police withheld fingerprint evidence from the Hutton Inquiry.

The text of the Refusal by Thames Valley Police follows:


Dear Dr Watt

Reference No: RFI2011000175

I write in connection to your request for information dated 06/03/2011 which for clarity I repeat below.

For each of the listed items was the absence of fingerprints on the item concerned communicated to the Hutton Inquiry and, where such evidence was communicated, on what date it was communicated to the Hutton Inquiry together with the Hutton Inquiry reference number for the document in which such information was communicated?

1. The knife found at Harrowdown Hill

2. The water bottle found at Harrowdown Hill

3. The blister packs for co-proxamol found at Harrowdown Hill

4. The mobile phone found at Harrowdown Hill

5. The watch found at Harrowdown Hill

As Thames Valley Police is aware it is my view that a number of individuals including Thames Valley Police officers may have perverted the course of justice with respect to the death of Dr. David Kelly. Such considerations apply, in my view, in 2003 and in 2010/11.

We regard your request for information as vexatious and by virtue of section 14(1) of the Act we are therefore not obliged to comply with it.

In reaching this decision, we have taken into account guidance on “Vexatious or repeated requests” issued by the Information Commissioner on 3 December 2008. We have also considered your request in the context of numerous previous requests on this subject made by you (19 including this one since 27 October 2010). In that context, we take the view that your current request can fairly be seen as obsessive, that complying with it would impose a significant burden on police officers and staff and that it lacks serious purpose or value. In our refusal notice dated 6 January 2011 in respect of other requests, we asked you to note that further requests by you on this subject may be treated as vexatious.

This letter represents a refusal notice under section 17 of the Act.

I have attached our Complaints Procedure to this email as the first stage of appealing this decision is by writing to me and requesting an Internal Review, detailing why you believe our decision is not in accordance with the FOIA.

FOI Request to Thames Valley Police re the "communications blackout" at Harrowdown Hill on 18th July 2003

This post puts on record a Freedom of Information request made to Thames Valley Police on 21st May 2011.

Thames Valley Police did not disclose to the Hutton Inquiry that any type of "communications blackout" was imposed.

Further, the "communications blackout", if it occurred, took place during the period when the "secret helicopter flight" took place at Harrowdown Hill, including the intriguing "secret helicopter landing".

This post, The Death of David Kelly - The Secret Helicopter Landing of 18th July 2003, contains the text of my communication of 3rd April 2011 to the Attorney General on the matter.

Here is the text of the Freedom of Information request.


This is a Freedom of Information request.

Press reports indicate that a "communications blackout" was imposed at Harrowdown Hill on 18th July 2003. This information (if accurate) was not, so far as I'm aware, disclosed to the Hutton Inquiry.

By "communications blackout" I mean any request or requirement by Thames Valley Police (or other agency) that radio or other communications equipment of any type, e.g. that in the ambulance of Vanessa Hunt and Dave Bartlett, should not be used.

1. On 18th July 2003 which individuals, after logging out of the outer cordon were asked not to leave the area or otherwise prevented by Thames Valley Police (or other agency) from leaving the area of Harrowdown Hill and/or Longworth Village?

2. Was a "communications blackout" imposed at or close to Harrowdown Hill at any time on 18th July 2003?

3. If so, at what time did the "communications blackout" start? (If there was more than one "communications blackout", I ask for such information for each blackout period.)

4. At what time did the "communications blackout" finish? (If there was more than one "communications blackout", I ask for such information for each blackout period.)

5. Was the imposition of the "communications blackout" related to the presence in the vicinity of Harrowdown Hill related to the secret helicopter flight from around 10.25 to 11.00?

6. What was the purpose of each period of "communications blackout"?

7. On whose authority was the "communications blackout" imposed?

Thank you

(Dr) Andrew Watt

FOI Request to Thames Valley Police re the start and end times of Operation Mason

In this post I record a Freedom of Information Request made to Thames Valley Police on 22nd May 2011.

If, as some hypothesise, the start time of Operation Mason was 14.30 on 17th July 2003 then Thames Valley Police has some serious explaining to do.

If the start time was, say, 23.40 on 17th July 2003 the interpretation of the nature of Operation Mason would be significantly different.

The text of the FOI request is as follows:


This is a Freedom of Information request.

1. On what date and at what time did Operation Mason start?

2. On what date and at what time did Operation Mason end?

Thank you

(Dr) Andrew Watt

FOI Internal Review Request to Thames Valley Police re Documents recovered from David Kelly's home

In this post I record a Freedom of Information Internal Review Request sent to Thames Valley Police earlier today.

The FOI Request to which the request for internal review relates is here: FOI Refusal by Thames Valley Police re Documents recovered from David Kelly's home .

The text of the Internal Review Request follows:


Mr. Hopgood,

I write to request an internal review of your initial decision.

I do not accept that my request was "vexatious".

My request asks for information that, so far as I'm aware, neither myself nor anybody else has previously requested.

Additionally, you seem to have failed appropriately to have taken into account the time span since any previous FOI requests by myself which have been answered. In doing that it appears to me that your decision is wrong in terms of the Act.

Further, the seeming declaration in the email of 1st April 2011 and previous correspondence that any question from me about the "subject" of Dr. David Kelly's death is "vexatious" seems to me to be a transparent attempt at obstructing the purpose of the Freedom of Information Act by yourself and Thames Valley Police.

To the best of my understanding there is no power given in the Act to declare a "subject" off limits. It seems to me that this is what you are seeking to do.

Additionally, as I have expressed in previous correspondence, I consider that some members of staff in Thames Valley Police in 2003 and in 2010-11 may have "perverted the course of justice" with respect to the concealment of what I believe to be the murder of Dr. David Kelly. I view your obstructiveness with respect to Freedom of Information requests in that context.

You are, I believe, aware that I have formally written to the Chief Officers of Thames Valley Police regarding the matter of the perceived perverting the course of justice both in 2003 and 2010-11.

In that context I believe that I have a "proper or justified cause" as expressed on page 2 of the ICO guidance to which you refer. ( http://www.ico.gov.uk/upload/documents/library/freedom_of_information/detailed_specialist_guides/awareness_guidance_22_vexatious_and_repeated_requests_final.pdf )

Since, in my opinion, the evidence indicates that Thames Valley Police is engaging in the process of perverting the course of justice in relation to a murder, it seems to me that a powerful case can be made on appeal to the Information Commissioner that I have a "proper or justified cause".

In the interests of transparency and public accountability, I anticipate that the text of this email will be posted on my "Chilcot's Cheating Us" blog: http://chilcotscheatingus.blogspot.com/ or my "Come Clean on Kelly" blog, http://comecleanonkelly.blogspot.com/ .

I look forward to your reply.

Thank you

(Dr) Andrew Watt

FOI Refusal by Thames Valley Police re Documents recovered from David Kelly's home

In thiis post I record a Freedom of Information Refusal by Thames Valley Police, sent by them on 12th May 2011.


Dear Dr Watt

Reference No: RFI2011000327

I write in connection to your request for information dated 23rd April 2011 which for clarity I repeat below.

1. How many documents were removed from David Kelly's home on 18th July 2003?

2. Was the search authorised? If so, by whom?

3. How many documents were removed from David Kelly's home on 19th July 2003?

4. Of the documents removed on 18th July 2003 how many were classified?

5. Of the documents removed on 19th July 2003 how many were classified?

6. Did the inventory of documents removed include a restricted document which referred to a possible honour for David Kelly?

7. Did any public sector organisation (other than Thames Valley Police) have staff present at the Kelly home during the searches referred to above? If so, which organisation(s) had staff present?

For the reasons given in our e-mail of 1 April in respect of a previous request made by you, we regard your request for information as vexatious and by virtue of section 14(1) of the Act we are therefore not obliged to comply with it.

This letter represents a refusal notice under section 17 of the Act.

I have attached our Complaints Procedure to this email as the first stage of appealing this decision is by writing to me and requesting an Internal Review, detailing why you believe our decision is not in accordance with the FOIA.


Sunday, 29 May 2011

FOI Request to Thames Valley Police - The "secret helicopter landing" etc on 18th July 2003

The following Freedom of Information Request was sent to Thames Valley Police earlier today:


This is a Freedom of Information request.

The following questions relate to the Thames Valley Police helicopter G-CHSU which landed at or near Harrowdown Hill at 10.55 on 18th July 2003.

1. Was any article or articles transferred from the helicopter to those on the ground? If so, what was the nature of the article(s)?

2. Was any article or articles transferred to the helicopter from those on the ground? If so, what was the nature of the article(s)?

3. Did any person disembark from the helicopter when it was on the ground?

4. Did any person leave the scene in the helicopter, other than those who had arrived by that same helicopter?

5. After it took off at approximately 11.00 did the helicopter fly to the area of Thames Valley Police headquarters at Kidlington?

6. Did the helicopter pass any article(s) to personnel on the ground in the area of Thames Valley Police headquarters or the nearby airfield? If so, what was the nature of those articles?

7. Did anyone disembark from the helicopter in the area of Thames Valley Police headquarters or at the nearby airfield?

8. On 18th July 2003 did anyone who was not a member of Thames Valley Police view photographs or other visual images of the body of Dr. David Kelly?

9. Was Assistant Chief Constable Michael Page present when images were shown to a party (or parties) other than members of Thames Valley Police?

10. Was Chief Constable Peter Neyroud present when images were shown to a party (or parties) other than members of Thames Valley Police?

11. Was information from such an "unofficial identification" passed on 18th July 2003 to parties outside Thames Valley Police?

12. Was information derived from a viewing (or viewings) of scene photographs or other images passed to any UK politician or anyone acting on behalf of such a politician?

In the interests of transparency I am copying this email to Dr. Malcolm Warner.

Thank you

(Dr) Andrew Watt